[123/365] accomplices
May. 3rd, 2021 11:12 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
Here's a thing I said on social media earlier today:
This is always what happens when I talk about these kinds of exhausting and disabling experiences I have -- I remember someone I barely even talk to any more making jokes about how I should have a cattle prod on the end of my cane. But my reactions to this have evolved quite a bit. At first I was totally there for it: I recognized my friend's responses as solidarity, I enjoyed the fantasies of cartoon violence and wished I could be a badass. Lately I've started to find such reactions a bit tiring and point-missing themselves. Today I hit some kind of critical mass where I figured out why I'm feeling unsettled.
Much as I sometimes love thwacking someone's car with my white cane when they stop in a crosswalk (I did this all the time in the way I used to get between the bus and Piccadilly station; gosh I won't miss going that way!), I'm not actually a huge fan of the "*thwack* Oh I didn't see you" type of joke.
It leaves me feeling incapable and incompetent. Even exploiting that for revenge on those who don't get it, or laughs with those who do, feels a bit like buying into the trope that bind people can't be expected to behave decently. Which I'm feeling increasingly uncomfortable with. I'm just wary of that "blind people are ignorant of their surroundings and/or can't be responsible for our actions" trope even if it's working "for" me, because I just hate it so much. It's embedded in our culture and it does so much damage.
Also, I'm aware of the power imbalance inherent in this interaction. If I fight back I'm the one likely to be "told off" or punished in some overt or covert way.
I'm really starting to find it unsatisfying even though I know my friends mean to be helpful and supportive because it's still saying the best I can hope for is to react well. I wish people would instead say "That shouldn't happen to you. I didn't know this could be a problem." I didn't, before it started happening to me! "Now that I know, I'll look out for it. I'll yell if I see disabled people not being treated properly, and I'm aware now that people actually expect blind people not to know how strangers are mistreating them." People who appear to not be white as well as appearing to be blind will particularly benefit from this, because the power imbalance between them and those taking advantage of them will be even greater.
I don't want cartoon violence and I don't want to be entertaining to bystanders or my friends hearing the anecdote later on. I need backup. I need accomplices.
You know, not that long ago Facebook tells me we had the sixth anniversary of the first time after I started using a white cane where people tried to sneak in front of me in a supermarket queue.I was pretty proud of that last line, implying how deeply I expect ableism in interactions with strangers. But it turns out another way things are getting "back to normal" or natural for me is that my friend's responses are things like "You should hit them with your cane because you can't see them" or "you should have a sword in your cane," sometimes even with an elaborate description of some blind character in a media property I haven't seen where the blind person is a total badass: their cane is probably a sword too.
I pretty much had a year off of this because of social distancing rules. People don't really keep anything like 2m apart but they did at least stop grabbing me, stop colliding with me and stop queue jumping me.
But this white woman in Tesco just tried to sneak in front of me. I guess nature is healing.
This is always what happens when I talk about these kinds of exhausting and disabling experiences I have -- I remember someone I barely even talk to any more making jokes about how I should have a cattle prod on the end of my cane. But my reactions to this have evolved quite a bit. At first I was totally there for it: I recognized my friend's responses as solidarity, I enjoyed the fantasies of cartoon violence and wished I could be a badass. Lately I've started to find such reactions a bit tiring and point-missing themselves. Today I hit some kind of critical mass where I figured out why I'm feeling unsettled.
Much as I sometimes love thwacking someone's car with my white cane when they stop in a crosswalk (I did this all the time in the way I used to get between the bus and Piccadilly station; gosh I won't miss going that way!), I'm not actually a huge fan of the "*thwack* Oh I didn't see you" type of joke.
It leaves me feeling incapable and incompetent. Even exploiting that for revenge on those who don't get it, or laughs with those who do, feels a bit like buying into the trope that bind people can't be expected to behave decently. Which I'm feeling increasingly uncomfortable with. I'm just wary of that "blind people are ignorant of their surroundings and/or can't be responsible for our actions" trope even if it's working "for" me, because I just hate it so much. It's embedded in our culture and it does so much damage.
Also, I'm aware of the power imbalance inherent in this interaction. If I fight back I'm the one likely to be "told off" or punished in some overt or covert way.
I'm really starting to find it unsatisfying even though I know my friends mean to be helpful and supportive because it's still saying the best I can hope for is to react well. I wish people would instead say "That shouldn't happen to you. I didn't know this could be a problem." I didn't, before it started happening to me! "Now that I know, I'll look out for it. I'll yell if I see disabled people not being treated properly, and I'm aware now that people actually expect blind people not to know how strangers are mistreating them." People who appear to not be white as well as appearing to be blind will particularly benefit from this, because the power imbalance between them and those taking advantage of them will be even greater.
I don't want cartoon violence and I don't want to be entertaining to bystanders or my friends hearing the anecdote later on. I need backup. I need accomplices.
(no subject)
Date: 2021-05-03 10:41 pm (UTC)Also whacking people/objects you can't see well - not gonna work. Or will break the cane...
I think there could be a cool campaign on "speaking out" when you see injustice whether that's racism, disablism or anything else. Don't be the bystander. Pay attention. Intervene, support the recipient of hassle, tell the perps off. Be the helpful one who helps...
Thank you for sharing how rotten sighted people can be. I wouldn't have known if it wasn't for you and others sharing these experiences.
(no subject)
Date: 2021-05-03 10:52 pm (UTC)It gives them the feeling that their work here is done, implicitly sending the message that we're individually responsible for reacting to this and that we're doomed to it happening forever because we can't stop it, we can't always block or pre-empt the behavior. Queue jumping is a relatively minor example but still I don't want to think it'll be happening to me forever, that it's just something I have to expect and that I should have a hilarious and photogenic strategy to hand for dealing with it. Ugh.
(no subject)
Date: 2021-05-04 01:50 am (UTC)when I write about people who grab me/grab my wheelchair/won't move out of my way when asked nicely
among other things, going over bumps in the wheelchair = physical pain for ME, so running over someone's foot would flare up MY physical pain for days...
Also, it's not safe to deliberately run over someone's foot - people get aggressive and threaten violence even when I say politely but firmly DON'T TOUCH ME.
(no subject)
Date: 2021-05-04 03:54 pm (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2021-05-04 11:14 pm (UTC)Amy is definitely one of the good people on Twitter. I wish I had her energy (I don't have any energy).
And yes to the endlessness. Even the small things are indicative of a wider lack of respect and consideration for others.
One thing talking to other disabled people really gives me is a strong sense of how to actually learn to be respectful, challenge my own biases and keep trying to be better. And it's so nice to be able to do tiny things that you know make someone's life a bit easier, one less stress, one less barrier.
(no subject)
Date: 2021-05-04 06:30 am (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2021-05-04 06:52 am (UTC)I was so shocked! This is why it ended up on Facebook; I just needed to share it with somebody. And then a white-cane using friend saw that and was like "oh yeah, that's totally a thing. It's like people talking really loudly and slowly at you once they see you're disabled." Which I think is much more recognized by the general public, the loud-talking, but in my friend's head this was just as normal. And the sneaky queue jumping has happened to me a bunch of times since so now I wouldn't mention it either except like I say I feel lile I had a year off.
People do really think anyone with a white cane has no idea of how they're acting; men stare at me even more blatantly than they do if I don't have the white cane too. Some people really tell you who they are when they think themselves unobserved.
(no subject)
Date: 2021-05-04 12:18 pm (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2021-05-04 03:57 pm (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2021-05-04 03:09 pm (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2021-05-04 04:01 pm (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2021-05-04 09:34 pm (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2021-05-04 06:10 pm (UTC)I actually shared my sense of what you said with a colleague who deals with racism in her teaching experience, and it resonated for her, too. So your honesty helped me do a better job of being a colleague and friend to her. Thank you for that.
When I first read this, I thought -- I want my students to read it. It speaks so clearly to focusing on the wrong part of a problem.